Suggest map difficulty re-ratings

[teini94]

HDP on off 2 Star? (Solo)
Last part not noob friendly
I saw soooo many tees who gabe up, crazy

Striped Clouds 5 Star
Why not!?

I know the new maps should be more supported (meaning of deen?)
I think they get supported bei themself.
Dont need help new maps with ratting down oldschool. I think thats no reason for lie to the real difficult of a oldschool map.
(You still great deen)

Falling Star 1(-2) brutal
( so hard) ( some guys fighting since 10 hours at the map)

Simple play Novice 4-5
Future race. Novice 3
Planet Venus moderate 1
Kobra 3 = (3-)4 stars Novice
Bbzz 2 stars old ( too easy)

What you think guys?

Mfg teini94

[Lady Saavik]

Maybe it was just bad idea to rate a map and give stars?
Maybe change it to 3 stars so it's easier to rate? Like easy - medium - hard?
People care too much about it
Look: that's the most active topic in whole forum. Crazy.
We have to do something about it.
Maybe just let players rate the map and look at average number. But who will care then? Everyone is like play the map and leave. Now that we have 600 maps it will be really hard.

[Ama]

Who cares about this topic beeing active you can see how many people care about the server

only thing i agree with teini is falling star to brutal

simple play isnt a novice map you have to catch your mate perfecty in every part and then the driving at the end is not for new players

old school maps can always be re-rated when you have a map you think has a wrong difficulty level the server was done in a hurry all maps were nearly added at once so its normal some maps will have stupid ratings when they werent tested

[Broken]

People like maps rated well, no problem to talk it out imo

[deen]

Moved Falling Star to Brutal. No idea about the rest. Map difficulty ratings will never be perfect, since some parts are harder for some people, but not for others.

[hi_leute_gll]

HDP on off 2 Star? (Solo)
Last part not noob friendly
I saw soooo many tees who gabe up, crazy

Solo is a hard server. Just 1 Star maps can be played by noobs. The rest of the map isn't very hard and it's not faily cause there are just teles.

Striped Clouds 5 Star
Why not!?

I think the fact that this map isn't finished yet should be enough to show how hard it is.
It has very hard solo parts and is very long.
I agree with teini.

Simple play Novice 4-5

The SimplePlay series was moved to novice a few days ago (or weeks).
I didn't understand why, cause it's to hard for novice, i think.

Future race. Novice 3

Was "discussed" about a week ago.
Some people say it's to easy and short. Other people say it's very faily.
I personally think it could be downgraded.

Planet Venus moderate 1

A difficult map to rate. The parts are all on novice level.
But: It's a very long novice map and there are a few parts wich are very faily like a moderate.
Don't know what to do there.

Kobra 3 = (3-)4 stars Novice

Kobra 3 is 4 stars. So what is ur suggestion?

Bbzz 2 stars old ( too easy)

Played it years ago. To long time to rate it.




Some words to the rating-system:

One problem is that some better player don't realize that the stars/points show a combination of how hard it is to finish and how much skill is needed to do the parts.

So they say that Planet Venus needs more time to finish as most [SI] maps but has less points.
What they don't see is that the [SI] maps have parts wich need more skill than the parts of Planet Venus.

For people wich much skill the parts on the [SI] maps are easy, too. But for an average player on a lower Moderate level the parts are very hard.

[teini94]

I am not angry or something only wanna speak about it

@ Lady Savik - I think the point-system with the Stars are nice.

teini94 wrote:HDP on off 2 Star? (Solo)
Last part not noob friendly
I saw soooo many tees who gabe up, crazy

hi_leute_gll wrote:
Solo is a hard server. Just 1 Star maps can be played by noobs. The rest of the map isn't very hard and it's not faily cause there are just teles.

Yes but it this part not the reason for the 8 points? (that is the question)

thx for your meanings guys!

I Hope we changed ddnet 1 * better

[hi_leute_gll]

Sry. Was my bad english.

Wanted to say, that i rate it 2 stars, but not more.

[teini94]

I agree with you

[imp]

Future Race: No beginner could ever do this and you want it on 3*..srsly?