Remove the banning system

Request help for teeworlds-related subjects (mapping, servers, ..).
For client issues, see our repositories (https://github.com/ddnet/ddnet/issues).
User avatar
beer panda
Posts: 23
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2015 5:13 pm
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/beer-32-panda/
Clan: A-Team

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by beer panda »

I remember in past on some servers there was such thing as /helper command and when u wrote it helper teleported to u and helped.So maybe possible solution could be removing voteban system and adding /moderator command to msg every moderator to come and ban insulting troll or blocker.
Chairn
Posts: 400
Joined: Sat Apr 11, 2015 5:05 pm
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/Chairn/
Clan: QuintessenZ

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by Chairn »

That would probably lead to abuse.
User avatar
stompie
Posts: 700
Joined: Thu Jun 18, 2015 2:40 pm
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/stompie/
Mapper profile: https://ddnet.tw/mappers/stompie/

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by stompie »

@Im 'corneum that would work in most cases but like Chairn said not alot of people play at the same time on sa but i guess ill have to sit with it for now thanks to all
\,,/(◣_◢)\,,/
User avatar
Soreu
Posts: 1371
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2014 2:47 pm
Location: Poland
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/Soreu
Mapper profile: http://ddnet.tw/mappers/Soreu
Clan: GSP

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by Soreu »

beer panda wrote:I remember in past on some servers there was such thing as /helper command and when u wrote it helper teleported to u and helped.So maybe possible solution could be removing voteban system and adding /moderator command to msg every moderator to come and ban insulting troll or blocker.
Lovely times of +DDRace, for example, but I guess it was used also in other mods
„Vince te ipsum”

         :3             |     GSP Founder     Honorary iMTGmember
Graphic-guy     |     Website & Forum Team Leader (Ex)     [ToP] Leader (Dead)

Last truly active: Sun Aug 28, 2016 11:13 pm - having great DDNet in both memory and heart
User avatar
Dr.Dre
Posts: 126
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 9:43 pm
Location: The Netherlands
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/Dr.Dre/

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by Dr.Dre »

It is impossible to track down IP's in the DDNet Client right?
I dont want to brag but...
When I hit, it's a headshot.
necropotame
Posts: 61
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2016 11:35 pm

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by necropotame »

In InfClass, I've disabled banvote. It's still better than being disturbed with funvote all the time. However, it's true that some players can block without facing any consequences. I think a solution could consist to replace banvote by a ban request system. If a player start a banvote, the server count this as ban request (but no vote start). If the server receive 3 requests, a banvote start like usual.
User avatar
Dr.Dre
Posts: 126
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 9:43 pm
Location: The Netherlands
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/Dr.Dre/

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by Dr.Dre »

necropotame wrote:In InfClass, I've disabled banvote. It's still better than being disturbed with funvote all the time. However, it's true that some players can block without facing any consequences. I think a solution could consist to replace banvote by a ban request system. If a player start a banvote, the server count this as ban request (but no vote start). If the server receive 3 requests, a banvote start like usual.
You can only request on IP's, people can change their names easily if they understand the system. I was thinking about this too, but it needs to be based on IP's
I dont want to brag but...
When I hit, it's a headshot.
User avatar
Soreu
Posts: 1371
Joined: Fri Aug 22, 2014 2:47 pm
Location: Poland
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/Soreu
Mapper profile: http://ddnet.tw/mappers/Soreu
Clan: GSP

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by Soreu »

They can either easily change their IPs though...
„Vince te ipsum”

         :3             |     GSP Founder     Honorary iMTGmember
Graphic-guy     |     Website & Forum Team Leader (Ex)     [ToP] Leader (Dead)

Last truly active: Sun Aug 28, 2016 11:13 pm - having great DDNet in both memory and heart
User avatar
Dr.Dre
Posts: 126
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 9:43 pm
Location: The Netherlands
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/Dr.Dre/

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by Dr.Dre »

I don't think people are so desperate for blocking on the DDNet server that they will change their IP. Maybe they will change it so that they can play on the servers again but I doubt there will be many continuing with blocking people after getting banned the first time.

Also there's probably a small amount of people who do know how to change their IP easily, the rest may be able to change thier IP but if they are desperate enough to do it, that is the question.

The little group of blockers who will do anything to stay blocking can't be stopped anyway.
I dont want to brag but...
When I hit, it's a headshot.
User avatar
kamillentee
Posts: 687
Joined: Sat Jul 26, 2014 11:47 pm
Player profile: http://ddnet.tw/players/kamillentee/
Clan: |*KoG*|

Re: Remove the banning system

Post by kamillentee »

Soreu wrote:They can either easily change their IPs though...
No, ita a very good idea. Right now you dont even need to change your ip to call a vote, so your argument is senseless. It would make the funvoting situation better. Still the amount of ban requests cant be a fixed number and should depend on the amount of players in the server.

And this would not lead to a solution for the full-server-block-problem timakro mentioned. Here you can start with limiting the vote participants to a number like 16. So just the first 16 votes would count in this example. Dunno, hi_leute had arguments against it, but you can try first if it solves the problem. If not revert it.
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests